"For historians of all fields, this book serves as an excellent model for how to read and analyze a variety of print sources, particularly the visual image. Buffington skillfully weaves multiple theoretical approaches, a mastery of Mexican historiography, and a careful and reliable interpretation of primary sources to produce a phenomenal book that is a must read for any scholar of journalism or Latin American history." — Sarah Foss, JHistory, H-Net Reviews
"[Buffington] is an insightful and sensitive observer of contemporary Mexican working-class culture, its language rhythms and word play, and its gendered norms and stinging, 'self-mocking' satire that few historians can match, perhaps none." — Rodney D. Anderson, American Historical Review
"Buffington . . . ambitiously and effectively utilizes the early-20th-century Mexico City penny press to analyze profound shifts in social and national dynamics during the last decade of the Porfiriato." — J. B. Kirkwood, Choice
"[A] beautifully written book, theoretically sophisticated yet unburdened by jargon. Few authors transport their readers to the streets of early twentieth-century Mexico City as e?ectively as Bu?ngton does." — Ingrid Bleynat, Journal of Latin American Studies
"[W]ith A Sentimental Education for the Working Man, Buffington bravely interrogates not a few of the interpretative commonplaces surrounding the Porfiriato, Mexican masculinity, and the working class. . . . [T]he text should be praised for opening up new discussions among scholars of Mexico from a range of fields." — Kevin Anzzolin, Textual Cultures
"Buffington makes an excellent case for the vital historical importance of the penny press.... [T]his is a readable and informative treatment of the working-class during an important period in Mexican history." — Evan C. Rothera, Journal of Global South Studies
"This is a nuanced and detailed study in which Buffington travels many avenues, eloquently it must be said, but the clearest direction of travel is in its commitment to putting aside the disciplinary projects of the modernising state, its agents and the liberal bourgeoisie that aimed to shape the psychology of the working man, and exploring instead the 'alternative sentimental education' that workers gained themselves from their own narrative media." — Gavin O'Toole, The Latin American Review of Books
"For readers who have ever been embarrassed by their ignorance of Porfirian workers’ slang, help is finally at hand. Robert Buffington’s exploration of the penny press that targeted Mexico City’s popular classes at the end of the 19th century is a complex and ambitious work—the ambition is reflected in the title—resting on uncommonly accomplished textual analyses." — Paul Gillingham, The Americas
"Buffington offers richly layered analyses of the cultural politics at work in texts and images that a less sophisticated historian might dismiss as simply comic sketches. The overall effect is stunning. Buffington succeeds in recasting the political world of urban Mexico on the eve of revolution . . . . He writes beautifully, and his translations come across as effortless. The book deserves a wide readership." — Ann Farnsworth-Alvear, Labor
"A Sentimental Education for the Working Man is easily accessible to the lay reader and remarkably free of jargon." — Jürgen Buchenau, Latin American Research Review
"Buffington’s monograph is an important contribution to Porfirian cultural studies. Buffington’s writing is crisp, fresh, and devoid of the difficult theoretical somersaults that characterized his earlier writing. In this approachable yet sophisticated analysis, he engages the literature on media studies, liberalism, labor history, and cultural and gender studies to produce a rich, provocative text." — Víctor M. Macías-González, HAHR
"Nobody that I know has systematically used the penny press genre to explore changing gender roles, and much less the historical development of subjectivities in modern Mexico. Although the book's focus is on working-class notions of masculinity, it argues for a broader influence of those notions during the twentieth century. Robert Buffington writes with grace, and few scholars, even writing in Spanish, would be able to reconstruct the meanings of the penny press language like he does."
— Pablo Piccato, author of The Tyranny of Opinion: Honor in the Construction of the Mexican Public Sphere