"Desjardins’s book contributes richly and significantly to star studies scholarship." — Cynthia Lucia, Film Quarterly
"[T]his meticulously researched book expertly draws from dazzling range material to produce a new understanding of how star images are produced and reproduced over time and to different ends." — Kristen Hatch, The Journal of American History
"Recycled Stars makes an original and sophisticated contribution to film and television studies and will be widely welcomed by readers and teachers. It is also illustrated with a delectable selection of stills that communicate the glamour and the sheer creepiness of the star images under discussion in equal measure." — Ruth Barton, Journal of American Studies
"Desjardins covers [Gloria Swanson and Lucille Ball] and much more in this fascinating tome, which is richly illustrated with frame grabs from kinescopes, as she considers the shifting landscape of mid-20th-century female celebrity. Highly recommended. Lower-division undergraduates through faculty; general readers." — G. A. Foster, Choice
"Well-written and using a rich variety of examples and methods, Recycled Stars is a useful and very readable addition to star studies, feminist media studies and film history." — Ellen Wright, Celebrity Studies
"In addition to being multidisciplinary, this book demonstrates the importance of considering different elements of film studies together. Areas that were previously separate in film studies, such as stardom, fandom, and industrial factors, present a completely different understanding of the field when brought together—an understanding that could greatly benefit future research and study." — Catherine Bednarz, International Journal of Communications
"With Recycled Stars Desjardins has thoroughly investigated female film stardom. The detail, variety, points of interest, and continuous historical perspective she brings to each chapter is truly impressive." — Esinam Beckley, .dpi
“Recycled Stars offers valuable insights into the relationships between stars and their publics, extending traditional scholarship by evaluating their impacts and consequences beyond a specific historical moment.” — Patrick Kent Russell, Journal of American Culture
"Recycled Stars is one of the fullest examinations of stardom that we have, and it makes a significant contribution to star studies and to broader considerations of film history and the use of primary sources in writing that history. Mary R. Desjardins makes innovative connections between media practices, from the film industry to television, tabloid journalism, and the legal system."
— Eric Smoodin, author of Regarding Frank Capra: Audience, Celebrity, and American Film Studies, 1930-1960
"Deftly synthesizing material ranging from fan magazines to cultural theory, Mary Desjardins's Recycled Stars offers a valuable contribution to star studies, gender studies, and media history alike with its dynamic exploration of female film star images regenerated for the small and its argument about the female star as a privileged commodity within media industries and the social imaginary."
— Christine Becker, author of It's the Pictures That Got Small: Hollywood Film Stars on 1950s Television