“Jazz among the Discourses and Representing Jazz represent something of an academic turning point in the mainstreaming of jazz studies in American academic circles. . . . [In] Representing Jazz . . . Gabbard has collected [a] dozen papers that explore the cross-fertilization of jazz in other media. Central to the argument of this collection is a challenge to the evolutionary, chronological model of jazz criticism. Instead, these critics situate jazz in its cultural moment, examining the racist and colonialist, the literary and filmic, undertaking a gestalt jazz criticism. . . . [T]hese essays provide a new dimension, another history of jazz.” — The Antioch Review
“[A] consistent sharpness, and impressively deft adaptation of both Jazz and the discursive channels that have for decades made meaning of this temporal phenomenon. Theory . . . throttles these collections into revealing that Jazz and contemporary thought are indeed compatible and mutually illuminating. Aiding and abetting the critical listener and viewer/reader, Gabbard’s selection of articles alone is worth commendation. . . . Gabbard has done a skillful service for the reader interested in collecting contemporary writings on Jazz. Likewise, those working in film studies, performance theory, and literary study will do well to peruse Representing Jazz’s many facets and disciplinary hoppings.” — Cadence
“[I]mportant for studying the interconnections between music, culture, and society. . . . [The contributors] share a commitment to understanding the complexity of the music they champion. Their efforts in opening up new perspectives for the analysis of music must be commended.” — American Book Review
“[T]hese collections contain some real gems.” — Lee B. Brown , The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism
“[T]hought-provoking, illuminating, and extremely valuable contributions reveal areas for further investigation and study. This is more than sufficient reason for these volumes to be in all academic libraries. Jazz scholarship is long overdue, and Gabbard’s collection deserves attention from those who are serious about this music because it demonstrates that there is another approach to the subject.” — Choice
“A groundbreaking anthology.” — Down Beat
“Both anthologies will provide valuable material for the serious student of jazz. . . . And the average reader with an interest in jazz will find some stimulating reading here.”
— ALLEGRO (Associated Musicians of Greater New York).
“Krin Gabbard, a specialist on jazz in cinema, has assembled two welcome volumes on jazz that include contributions from the fields of film, literature, dance, musicology, history, and art history. The collections share a commitment to developing an interdisciplinary vision for jazz studies that includes engagement with postmodern and poststructural critical theories. . . . Historians of American music are likely to find Jazz among the Discourses a particularly useful volume, since it emphasizes historiographic issues and collects several important previously published works.” — American Music
“Specialists in Jazz studies will need to contend with many of the claims made in these volumes, and social historians and scholars interested in American popular culture will certainly find valuable scholarship here. . . . Reading the volumes is rather like listening to a many-layered musical call and response between contributors.” — The Journal of American History
“The essays in Representing Jazz and Jazz among the Discourses, companion anthologies edited by Krin Gabbard, seek to dismantle constricting definitions of jazz by exposing the music—as it has been played, imagined, and conceptualized—to interpretive methods in critical theory and cultural studies.” — Voice Literary Supplement
"A most valuable and engrossing book that will surely be read by all those who write about jazz. Fans will also seek it out. It offers a wealth of perspectives, allowing the reader to learn what people in other disciplines have to say about jazz." — Lewis Porter, author, with Michael Ullman, of Jazz: From Its Origins to the Present
"A remarkable variety of voices and perspectives, and yet the overall thrust of the collection—to establish the groundwork on which a field of jazz studies could be founded—is quite clear. Jazz Among the Discourses will have an obvious impact on musicology, simply because nothing like it has ever been attempted." — Scott DeVeaux, University of Virginia